Rethinking The Donor Fatigue Myth


Donor fatigue. It’s a myth.  Donors don’t get tired of giving.  In recent years, we’ve seen incredible shows of generosity both to nonprofits and through other channels like GoFundMe and other mutual aid.  

What donors do get tired of are transactional asks, lazy fundraising, and impersonal communications.   After years of support, donors who don’t know if and how their gifts are making a difference or–worse– only feel like they hear from the nonprofit they support when they’re asking for something, it’s easy to see why there’s a decline in enthusiasm and participation. Just because a relationship has gone cold, doesn’t mean it’s over..yet. There are ways to rekindle the flame with stale donor relationships and reignite their passion for your cause.

Understanding Donor “Fatigue”

First, let’s acknowledge the culprit. Donors are bombarded each and every day with requests from various organizations, which can cause generic solicitations to lose their impact. Donors crave authenticity and a sense of connection. They want to know that they matter to your organization and that their gift of whatever size is helpful and making a difference.  If your appeals sound like every other fundraising email, you’ll get tuned out.

There also may be a lack of impact reporting. Have you ever heard of doom scrolling? Donors want to see the tangible difference their contributions make. Vague statements about “making a difference” aren’t enough. It’s important to cut through the urgent appeals with stories of success and how your mission is helping change lives.

Donors also may be feeling undervalued. They need to feel that they are more than just wallets – they’re passionate individuals who want to feel appreciated and heard. 

Identifying Signs of Donor Disengagement

Track Donation Trends

  • Track donor retention rates. How many donors are continuing to donate year-over-year?
  • Look for a decrease in overall donations compared to previous periods. This could indicate a decline in donor engagement across your program.
  • Analyze individual donor giving patterns. Are regular donors giving less frequently or smaller amounts?

Monitor Engagement

  • Are donors opening your emails or clicking on your campaign donation links? A decrease in metrics like click-throughs and response rates could signal disinterest.
  • Are donors responding to your calls to action, such as volunteering or attending events?
  • Is there a decline in your social media audience engagement? 

Donor Segmentation

  • Analyze your donor base by segmenting them based on giving history, demographics, or preferred communication channels. Are there groups that seem more susceptible to fatigue than others? Analytics software can use predictive modeling to help you pinpoint who’s most at risk of lapsing. (Reach out to the Windmill Hill Consulting team to learn more.)

This data analysis can identify trends that suggest donor disengagement. Then, you can develop strategies to target those who may need a little extra attention. 

Rekindling the Flame: Strategies for Donor Re-Engagement

Now that we understand the cause, let’s explore solutions. There are effective ways to re-engage your supporters, and the foundation for a successful approach comes down to appreciation and solicitation. 

  • Embrace Two-Way Communication: Don’t just ask, listen! Encourage feedback from your donors through surveys, polls, or focus groups. Understanding their perspectives allows you to tailor your communications and programs to better meet their needs.
  • The Power of “Remember When?”: Reignite past connections by reminding donors of their initial passion for your cause. Share a “supporter record” that highlights their last gift date.
  • Personalization is Key: Your donors are real people, with real names. Adding personalization wherever possible will help ensure your message is resonating with them. The personal touch shows you care.
  • Offer Unique Opportunities: Think outside the box! Provide exclusive content, early access to events, or virtual tours of your facilities for loyal donors. Consider hosting online donor forums or webinars featuring industry experts to cultivate a sense of community.
  • Volunteer Match Making: Assign a volunteer to a loyal donor to connect them even deeper to your cause. The volunteer can send handwritten thank you notes, and even help inspire the donor to get more involved.
  • Birthday Fundraiser: Collect the birthday information of your donors, and send them an automated birthday card that thanks them for their support. Who doesn’t want to feel special on their birthday?
  • Email Trivia: Send out a mini-email campaign that is a series of trivia questions about your organization and the importance of its mission, and reveal the answer once the someone clicks through the email. 
  • Exclusive Moments: Make donors feel valued by offering exclusive experiences. This could be early access to events, invitations to meet program beneficiaries, or behind-the-scenes glimpses into your organization’s work.
  • Gamification Incentives: Consider a tiered system where donors unlock small rewards (i.e., a branded sticker or bookmark) when they reach donation milestones. Or, organize a “bracket challenge” during a relevant event and have donors compete for a prize when they choose to donate. 

There are so many options to consider when thinking through fun, new ideas to get your donors re-engaged.

Proactive Strategies to Prevent Attrition

While re-engagement is crucial, preventing attrition is even better. There are some steps you can take before your donors drift away. 

Cultivate Relationships

Don’t just reach out when you need money. Maintain consistent communication throughout the year, providing updates and opportunities to connect beyond giving.

Transparency is Key

Be as upfront as you can about your organization’s finances and how donations are used. This builds trust and encourages continued support.

Provide Flexible Options

Offer donors a variety of ways to give, including recurring donations, volunteering opportunities, or in-kind contributions. This allows them to support your cause in a way that aligns with their preferences.

Never Enough Thank You’s

Do your donors know just how much they mean to you? Nurture your relationship and make sure they understand the impact they’re having on your mission.

Analyze Communication Strategies

Are you bombarding donors with too many requests? Consider the volume and frequency of your communication. Is your messaging overly negative or focused solely on fundraising? Emphasize the impact of donations and success stories.

Evaluate Your Donor Journey

Map out the touchpoints a donor has with your organization, from the very first interaction to ongoing engagement. Does every interaction provide value and help deepen the connection?

More Than Just A Wallet

Let’s spark joy, not fatigue! Engaged donors are the fuel that propels our mission. Let’s ditch the vague, transactional approach and instead work to build genuine connections. 

Site Design & Development North Star Sites